Showing posts with label Education in UAE. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Education in UAE. Show all posts

Thursday, 3 November 2011

Amid the din of reform, teachers' voices are drowned out



May 22, 2011 

If I was a teacher getting a Dh20,000-a-month salary, free rent, utilities, a car allowance and free airfare home in the summer, I would do my best to keep my pupils, their parents and the administrators all in smiles. Right?
No thanks. Teaching in UAE is akin to being a lab mouse in a labyrinth. One minute it's rote learning, worksheets and a regimented classroom. Then it's technological theories about what makes learning "meaningful". You have to make it fun, they say. Now pupils only respond to comedians, wizards and tyrants. With a little dazzle and some child-friendly jokes, you might be a success.
They couldn't pay me enough. What starts out as a seemingly good job turns into a scene out of the movie Gladiator.
"State-of-the-moment" teaching relies too much on instructional acrobatics. Just as you stop to catch your breath, the principal catches you sitting in your chair. "Teachers don't sit anymore, that is so 19th century," she chides. Gone are the days of teaching "my way", the days of closing the door, creating a world between you and your pupils where learning and growth go together.
Then comes the day when you hear your dream of becoming a great teacher burst overhead. Although your brand-new briefcase is overloaded with the latest edition of pedagogy, the other teachers in your group missed that workshop so they are often at your door, creeping in to steal your ideas and techniques. Then they run over to the department head and claim intellectual rights, leaving you in the dust.
For those teachers who stay in the job, life in the classroom can be as funny as it is bewildering. Some might dazzle you with rap lyrics or moonwalking.
Then again, if you are a foreign teacher, that strange look on pupils' faces has an explanation. "Is she Kate from Lost or Nia Long from Big Mamma's House?" they ask each other. If you are a Muslim wearing an abayah, they will think their eyes are playing games on them because you look so familiar but act so differently.
Actually, I'm just playing. Really, the children aren't thinking that hard. For the most part they are just trying to figure out what you want them to do or patiently waiting for that one student who understands the assignment to finish so that they can start copying.
If you are really lucky, you work in one of those outstanding schools where all the head teachers are all on the same page. Your children are attentive and try hard to do well. The money is good, too. Most outstanding schools have career teachers who have to be up to snuff. No second chances or slipping through the cracks at a school like that.
For those of you on the front lines of education, I would suggest a jar of lavender oil for relaxation and headaches, some really soft sofa pillows for when you pass out 10 minutes after you arrive home, and a vibrating foot bath so that when you wake up in the morning, you won't feel like you still have your shoes on.
Teaching is hard work and you'll need these creature comforts just to survive. Stress is the reason that many teachers are leaving the profession. It's stress that hangs around like an unwanted freeloader, eating up every minute of your day.
In all of the news about education, the voices of teachers are ominously missing. They should matter the most in this conversation. Some think that schools are better now than before, others are not so sure.
The key to any successful school is consistency, dedicated staff, recognition for hard work and adequate pay. The lack of any of these infects teachers, pupils and their parents with a bad case of wanderlust, as they make their way through the school-reform maze hoping for a better life both inside and outside of the classroom.

Maryam Ismail is a sociologist and teacher who divides her time between the US and the UAE

Reading, writing and 'rithmetic - it all adds up to high fees



Jul 4, 2011 

What is at the heart of the foggy, tangled maze of why schools cost so much? It's a lack of transparency about what, exactly, parents are paying for.
Every parent I know can list their problems and questions relating to their children's schools - not to mention suspicions of outright thievery. Even after Dubai's inspections, schools are still putting one over on parents and laughing all the way to the bank.
Don't get me wrong, the inspections by the Knowledge and Human Development Authority (KHDA) have been very useful, putting a speed bump in front of breakneck fee hikes, but many parents feel that more needs to be done.
Preparing for the start of the new term in September, my nephew had been looking for a school for his daughter. Since he's new in the country, he asked me to look around for him. I went straight to the grapevine, asking my friends and neighbours how they felt about their children's schools.
One of my friends has a child at one of the schools my nephew was interested in. She liked the school, but I wasn't so impressed when I checked its website and found out that the school charged extra for Arabic and English-language classes. How can they get away with charging extra for core classes?
Transportation fees are another thing that irks parents. One parent told me that she and her husband were being charged Dh8,000 a year for their child to be driven 15 minutes to school. For that kind of money, it just makes sense to drive them yourself.
Many of the schools use buses that can seat 50 pupils. Fifty times Dh8,000 adds up to a lot of money. Are we supposed to believe that Dh400,000 in transport fees is simply to cover costs as some schools claim?
I had to take my heart pills after seeing the fees that some schools have been demanding. "It's a mafia," my neighbour told me, and I couldn't argue with her. Another school was asking for a deposit of nearly Dh30,000 on top of regular tuition and registration fees, which totalled nearly Dh50,000 for kindergarten. Why am I thinking of The Sopranos instead of the A-B-C's?
It wasn't long ago when you could find advertisements in the classified ads with parents offering used books for sale. Also, uniforms were passed down from older siblings who attended the same school. It was a way of defraying costs, but not anymore. Parents are forced to buy new uniforms and books that they don't need and to pay for materials that come late or not at all.
When searching for a school these days, you need to keep your calculator handy. My Quran teacher told me that she had been asked to pay Dh490 ($133) for a book that I know costs $49 on the publisher's website. She refused, saying: "Why should I buy it when I can get it from my friend?"
They rejoined: "We've changed the books this year." She didn't budge however.
Another trend is that some schools are teaching only a portion of the curriculum in school, while offering another portion of the lessons for an extra fee. There are the usual, non-refundable registration fees, but Dh12,000 for an extra intensive English class for Grade One? That's outrageous.
They use the excuse that there's no time to finish during school hours. Another friend was livid when she learnt that in order for her son to graduate, he would have to take extra lessons that cost up to Dh1,500 per subject.
Parents just want a fair deal for their hard-earned money. They want schools that are keeping their promise to do what is best for the pupils in their care. I know that authorities have put restrictions on fees that schools can charge, but it might be helpful to look into the epidemic of hidden charges that seem to arise. This would help to ease the minds of parents who are lying awake at night wondering where they will find the money to pay for their child's education.

Maryam Ismail is a teacher who divides her time between the United States and the UAE